Why Your 5-Star Safety Car Is Not as Safe as You Think

Let me be immediately. When a person says their vehicle has a 5-Star Safety Rating, a feel of alleviation kicks in robotically. Like, now nothing terrible can clearly happen. But truth is a bit messier. I even have spent the remaining 10 years inner this industry from test tracks to actual toll road crash websites. And this is exactly in which the distance among rating and truth shows up.

A 5-megastar badge does not imply the auto will never fail in an accident. It best way the car completed properly in a limited, controlled check. That’s it. Real-existence injuries are in no way managed.

Where Crash Tests and Real Accidents Start to Differ

Crash tests manifest at a set pace. Fixed angle. Fixed dummy. On actual roads? Speed is never regular, angles are unpredictable, and you in no way understand whether or not you may hit a divider, a pole, or a truck.

I do not forget protecting an coincidence concerning a famous 5-megastar rated compact SUV. It become a facet impact, no longer a frontal one. The B-pillar pushed in so much that the rear passenger became significantly injured. The proprietor stored saying simplest one aspect, this automobile had five stars. That second made me understand how little the score gadget simply explains to consumers.

Safety Ratings Are Variant-Specific, People Ignore This

This happens all of the time. The manufacturer sends the bottom variant for crash trying out. Steel wheels, fundamental indoors, no sunroof. But at the showroom, you purchase the pinnacle variant with a massive sunroof, more wiring, brought weight, and every so often even slight structural modifications.

Once I without delay requested a provider whether the pinnacle variation was examined. He smiled and said, sir everything is the equal. He stated it very casually. But the reality is, it isn't always exactly the equal. Small changes in weight distribution and pressure can create a big distinction at some stage in effect.
 

Indian Roads Are the Biggest Enemy of Safety Ratings

This is some thing we must receive quicker as opposed to later. Our roads are some distance from ideal. Open drains, badly designed dividers, stray animals, and maximum dangerously, trucks with nearly useless underride protection.

In crash assessments, vehicles hit flat barriers. In real existence, motors slide under vans. Whether it's far a 5-superstar vehicle or a 2-star one, physics will do its task. A strong structure helps, however if the effect factor itself is inaccurate, ratings can't store the situation.

Driver Behaviour Has No Safety Test

This component by no means gets sufficient interest. Overconfidence. I even have in my opinion visible humans deal with a 5-big name badge like a free skip. High speeds, unfastened seat belts, youngsters sitting on laps.

One incident still sticks with me. A younger owner, a logo-new five-megastar sedan, using properly above secure velocity internal city limits. A curve got here, control become lost. The car blanketed him decently, but the steering enter turned into incorrect and braking came too late. Safety systems are not gods. Not even near.

Airbags and Electronics Do Not Work in Every Situation

Airbags are smart, but now not that smart. In low-velocity facet influences, they from time to time do no longer set up. In rollovers, timing can be off. Electronics take selections in milliseconds, however if the character of the crash falls outdoor their good judgment, the device remains silent.

During a check drive of an EV, I for my part experienced a software glitch. The dashboard iced over. Now believe something comparable occurring in the intervening time of effect. Rare, sure. Impossible, no. And no score sheet talks approximately this.

Marketing Simplifies Safety Too Much

Brands say most secure car in the section. But which phase? Which kind of crash? What pace? All that is written in tiny disclaimers that nobody surely reads.

The problem is not with the rating device itself. The difficulty is expectations. People anticipate 5-megastar way zero danger. As a ways as I am involved, safety is a aggregate of automobile, avenue, speed, and driving force. If one is robust and the rest are susceptible, the final results is apparent.

So What Should a 5-Star Rating Actually Mean?

I am not pronouncing safety scores are vain. Not in any respect. They are an excellent start line. They tell you how robust the simple structure is. Nothing more. Real safety comes whilst you force within limits, wear seat belts nicely, and treat ratings as self belief mixed with caution.

In the cease, just don't forget this. A five-star score gives you a threat to live to tell the tale. It does not provide you with a guarantee. And the sooner we understand that, the safer all of us turn out to be.

POLL

Is Why Your 5-Star Safety Car Is Not as Safe as You Think the right direction?

Support Neutral Against Not Sure

Vote

Videos For This

Kia Seltos Crash Test

Tata Tiago Crash Test

Hyundai i20 Crash Test

💬 Join the Discussion

No discussions yet. Be the first to start one!

+

Gaurav Jha Gaurav Jha is a seasoned automotive journalist and digital media expert with a passion for new technology, electric vehicles, and unbiased product reviews. As the founder of GearChoice.in, he aims to empower readers with transparent, well-researched information about the latest cars, gadgets, and mobility trends.

More from this author →